
Case studyInternal Controls
Concurrent audit of a bank's risk management department
Financial Services & Banking
Prior professional experience of team members
Scope of work
Monthly revalidation of the logic, formulae and source data behind capital adequacy (CRAR, risk-weighted assets and capital computation), the leverage ratio, the Large Exposures Framework, expected credit loss, the liquidity coverage and net stable funding ratios, the liquidity return and stock-approach ratios, the structural liquidity statement, lending rate benchmarks (MCLR, base rate, BPLR and EBLR), interest rate sensitivity, cash positions against retention limits, the business continuity plan, reputation risk, key risk indicators, operational loss data and SLR maintenance.
Approach and solutions
Each return was traced from source data through every calculation step to the figure reported, and recomputed independently against the applicable Reserve Bank of India directions and the bank's approved policies, including the treasury and market risk policies and ALCO decisions. Every area carried an auditor's observation with a risk rating of low, medium or high; differences were discussed with the department, and a rectification certificate recorded which observations had been regularised by the close of each audit period.
- 06Workstreams
- 06Key deliverables
- 01Related service
- 01Sector
Implementation and key milestones
Capital and leverage
Weekly testing of account-level and summary risk-weighted asset reports for the largest borrowers by sanction, covering the mapping of external ratings to risk weights, capital market exposures and non-performing accounts; review of CET1, Additional Tier 1 and Tier 2 capital with regulatory adjustments such as deferred tax assets and the discount on revaluation reserves; and of the leverage ratio exposure measure across on-balance sheet, derivative, securities financing and off-balance sheet items.
Large exposures and credit loss
Review of single and group exposures above the framework threshold, the identification of connected counterparties through control and economic interdependence, and the treatment of exempt sovereign exposures; and segment-wise testing of the expected credit loss workbook across corporate, agricultural, non-agricultural, investment and other financial asset portfolios.
Liquidity
Verification of high-quality liquid assets and stable funding in the LCR and NSFR, liquidity ratios under the stock approach, and maturity buckets in the structural liquidity statement, including the behavioural study for non-maturity items, with the largest gaps analysed against the approved limits.
Interest rates
Recomputation of MCLR from the marginal cost of borrowings, return on net worth, negative carry on CRR, operating cost and tenor premium, with reset and benchmark rules tested for each tenor; and of interest rate sensitivity through traditional gap analysis for earnings at risk and duration gap analysis for the market value of equity.
Cash and SLR
Zone-wise cash holdings compared with retention limits and the related insurance cover; SLR maintained against the requirement on net demand and time liabilities and the policy ceiling, with the composition of the investment portfolio by category.
Operational and other risks
Review of the business continuity plan for critical banking applications, the reputation risk score across quantitative and qualitative parameters, the key risk indicator score and the movement in red indicators, and loss events analysed by Basel event type and cause.
Key deliverables
- Monthly concurrent audit report covering each risk area
- Auditor's observations with risk ratings and recommendations
- Independent recomputation workings for regulatory returns
- Exception register for logic, formula and data errors in systems and spreadsheets
- Suggested refinements to risk measurement methods
- Rectification certificate and follow-up of open observations
Client identities have been withheld in accordance with applicable ICAI guidelines, professional ethics and confidentiality obligations.
This reflects the prior professional experience of individual members of the firm's team, including experience gained before joining the firm. It is not a representation of work performed by the firm.
This material is general information about the nature of professional work and the experience of the firm's team. It does not identify any client, is not a representation of any particular client's circumstances and is not a guarantee of results. Each engagement depends on its own facts and agreed scope.
