A recurring-revenue dashboard on a curved monitor, with a server room behind glass

Case studyAccounting and Financial Reporting

Accounting, tax and controls review of a subscription software group

Technology, IT & Digital Services

Prior professional experience of team members

Scope of work

A phased review of accounting and related policies, tax compliance and the procure-to-pay controls: the general ledger and financial statements; revenue and deferred revenue across the full billing-to-receipt cycle; employee stock options; capitalisation of development costs; month-end and year-end provisioning; vendor and customer reconciliations and ageing; disclosures under Schedule III and the Accounting Standards; consolidation and intercompany transactions; GST, TDS and direct tax compliance; transfer pricing and FEMA; and process mapping, control testing and a delegation of authority framework.

Approach and solutions

The review was carried out partly on the company's premises and partly remotely, in phases sequenced so that findings from the accounting review informed the tax testing. Each area was walked through with its process owner and tested on samples selected on a risk basis. Every observation carried its background, the risk and impact, a risk rating and a control rating, a recommendation, the person responsible and a target date, with year-wise rectification workings shared separately. Policies were drafted with the finance team and agreed with management.

  • 06Workstreams
  • 08Key deliverables
  • 05Related services
  • 01Sector

Implementation and key milestones

  1. Revenue

    Product-wise assessment of performance obligations to decide which subscriptions are recognised at a point in time and which over time; review of subscriptions and usage credits released before invoicing or payment, unbilled revenue, credit notes passed for bad debts, and the mapping of currency rates, destination countries and test accounts; and reconciliation of deferred revenue with balances on the billing platform.

  2. Stock options and intangibles

    Recognition of employee stock option expense over the vesting period from a grant-date valuation using an option pricing model, as the ICAI Guidance Note requires, with the reserve classified within other equity; and a policy for capitalising development costs under AS 26, separating the research and development phases.

  3. Provisions and reconciliations

    Testing of under-provisions, over-provisions and unused provisions, incentive accruals and aged balances; a provisioning template for user departments and a three-way match for expenses; and a policy for periodic vendor and customer reconciliations, balance confirmations and the review of long-aged and unadjusted items.

  4. Reporting

    Review of standalone and consolidated financial statements against Schedule III and the Accounting Standards, a disclosure-complete financial statement structure, and evaluation of pending tax litigation for contingent liability disclosure under AS 29.

  5. Tax

    TDS deducted in the books reconciled with challans and quarterly returns, section and rate mapping in the vendor master, and the tax audit report reconciled with the books; GST cash and credit ledgers reconciled with the books and input tax credit in GSTR-3B with GSTR-2B; and transfer pricing reviewed for the agreed mark-up against the benchmarking study, the safe harbour option, Form 3CEAA and an intercompany royalty arrangement.

  6. Controls

    Procure-to-pay process mapping covering approvals, vendor onboarding, invoice processing and employee reimbursements; risk-based sample testing of authorisations, vendor master controls and segregation of duties; and benchmarking against the COSO framework on a five-level maturity scale.

Key deliverables

  • Accounting and compliance review report with risk-rated observations
  • Year-wise rectification and prior period adjustment workings
  • Revenue recognition and deferred revenue policy, with an approval workflow for bad debts
  • Policies on capitalisation of intangibles and on month-end and year-end provisioning
  • Financial statement structure aligned with Schedule III
  • Tax compliance review, tax risk register and compliance calendar
  • Transfer pricing and cross-border compliance note
  • Risk control matrix, delegation of authority framework and procure-to-pay process map

Client identities have been withheld in accordance with applicable ICAI guidelines, professional ethics and confidentiality obligations.

This reflects the prior professional experience of individual members of the firm's team, including experience gained before joining the firm. It is not a representation of work performed by the firm.

This material is general information about the nature of professional work and the experience of the firm's team. It does not identify any client, is not a representation of any particular client's circumstances and is not a guarantee of results. Each engagement depends on its own facts and agreed scope.

All case studies